Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

Add natural=valley #1589

Open
wants to merge 2 commits into
base: master
Choose a base branch
from
Open

Add natural=valley #1589

wants to merge 2 commits into from

Conversation

zstadler
Copy link
Contributor

#274 requested the addition of several natural features.
#1202 addressed most of them.
However, natural=valley ways were excluded from the PR.
Following the discussion about this exclusion, it looks like it would be fine to add them and resolve #274

@zstadler
Add natural=valley
29b0416 
At the time, `natural=valley` ways were excluded from openmaptiles#1202

Following the discussion there, it looks like it would be fine to add them.
@github-actions
Copy link

github-actions bot commented Oct 21, 2023 •
edited

Results evaluating commit 5bf2ca1 (merged with base e61442c as fbe99ef). See run details.

PostgreSQL DB size in MB: 4939 ⇒ 4939 (0.0% change)

step total time change user time change
1_data 2:49.94 -0.9% 1.84 3.4%
2_osm 2:06.83 -1.7% 1.76 -1.7%
3_wikidata 0:22.88 5.0% 0.98 4.3%
4_sql 6:58.78 -0.3% 1.87 -6.0%
test-perf 10:29.63 0.1% 0.54 -6.9% 

Per-test generation speed (longer is better)
#######################################################################################
████████████████████ 712.7 tiles/s +2.6% in test bbox_test_1, 117459 tiles in 0:02:44.7
█                     56.1 tiles/s -1.9% in test bbox_test_2, 1511 tiles in 0:00:26.8  
█                     68.1 tiles/s +0.2% in test bbox_test_3, 6501 tiles in 0:01:35.4  
                       8.8 tiles/s -0.1% in test bbox_test_4, 2723 tiles in 0:05:09.6  

Per-test average tile sizes (shorter is better)
########################################################################################
                     168.3 per tile -0.0% in test bbox_test_1, 117459 tiles in 0:02:44.7
█                     2.9K per tile -0.0% in test bbox_test_2, 1511 tiles in 0:00:26.8  
█                     2.7K per tile +0.0% in test bbox_test_3, 6501 tiles in 0:01:35.4  
████████████████████ 33.1K per tile -0.0% in test bbox_test_4, 2723 tiles in 0:05:09.6  

Per-zoom generation speed (longer is better)
#####################################################################################
                                   1.8 tiles/s -18.5% at z0, 4 tiles in 0:00:02.2    
                                  11.5 tiles/s -3.4% at z1, 6 tiles in 0:00:00.4     
                                   7.4 tiles/s -22.5% at z2, 6 tiles in 0:00:00.7    
                                   9.7 tiles/s +10.1% at z3, 6 tiles in 0:00:00.5    
                                   8.5 tiles/s +22.3% at z4, 6 tiles in 0:00:00.6    
                                  11.8 tiles/s +2.5% at z5, 9 tiles in 0:00:00.7     
█                                 15.2 tiles/s +17.1% at z6, 11 tiles in 0:00:00.6   
                                  11.3 tiles/s -6.7% at z7, 20 tiles in 0:00:01.7    
██                                26.3 tiles/s +16.0% at z8, 48 tiles in 0:00:01.7   
█████                             62.3 tiles/s +18.2% at z9, 132 tiles in 0:00:02.1  
█                                 20.6 tiles/s +4.6% at z10, 437 tiles in 0:00:21.2  
███████████████████████          282.5 tiles/s +6.1% at z11, 1603 tiles in 0:00:05.6 
███                               44.9 tiles/s +4.0% at z12, 6154 tiles in 0:02:16.9 
████████████                     143.3 tiles/s -0.5% at z13, 24161 tiles in 0:02:48.5
████████████████████████████████ 378.9 tiles/s -1.2% at z14, 95591 tiles in 0:04:12.3

Per-zoom average tile sizes (shorter is better)
#####################################################################################
█████                           16.8K per tile ±0.0% at z0, 4 tiles in 0:00:02.2     
█████████████████████████████   89.2K per tile ±0.0% at z1, 6 tiles in 0:00:00.4     
███████████████████████████     83.5K per tile ±0.0% at z2, 6 tiles in 0:00:00.7     
████████████                    39.4K per tile ±0.0% at z3, 6 tiles in 0:00:00.5     
████████                        25.1K per tile ±0.0% at z4, 6 tiles in 0:00:00.6     
███                             10.1K per tile ±0.0% at z5, 9 tiles in 0:00:00.7     
███                             11.8K per tile ±0.0% at z6, 11 tiles in 0:00:00.6    
████                            14.5K per tile ±0.0% at z7, 20 tiles in 0:00:01.7    
███                             11.4K per tile -0.0% at z8, 48 tiles in 0:00:01.7    
██                               6.6K per tile +0.0% at z9, 132 tiles in 0:00:02.1   
█                                3.7K per tile +0.0% at z10, 437 tiles in 0:00:21.2  
                                 2.0K per tile +0.0% at z11, 1603 tiles in 0:00:05.6 
                                 1.5K per tile +0.0% at z12, 6154 tiles in 0:02:16.9 
                                787.5 per tile -0.0% at z13, 24161 tiles in 0:02:48.5
                              1,015.4 per tile +0.0% at z14, 95591 tiles in 0:04:12.3

Generated 128,194 tiles in 0:09:56.8, 214.8 tiles/s +0.6%, 1,047.1 bytes/tile +0.0%
Saving results to /tileset/pr-results.json
expand for details... 
Hardware reset test-perf ...
Hardware reset test-perf done
Comparing results with a previous run created 0:59:29.1 ago: /tileset/results.json
Connecting to PostgreSQL at postgres:5432, db=openmaptiles, user=openmaptiles...
* version()                       = PostgreSQL 14.5 (Debian 14.5-1.pgdg110+1) on x86_64-pc-linux-gnu, compiled by gcc (Debian 10.2.1-6) 10.2.1 20210110, 64-bit
* postgis_full_version()          = POSTGIS="3.2.3 2f97b6c" [EXTENSION] PGSQL="140" GEOS="3.9.0-CAPI-1.16.2" PROJ="7.2.1" LIBXML="2.9.10" LIBJSON="0.15" LIBPROTOBUF="1.3.3" WAGYU="0.5.0 (Internal)"
* jit                             = off
* shared_buffers                  = 128MB
* work_mem                        = 4MB
* maintenance_work_mem            = 64MB
* effective_cache_size            = 4GB
* effective_io_concurrency        = 1
* max_connections                 = 100
* max_worker_processes            = 8
* max_parallel_workers            = 8
* max_parallel_workers_per_gather = 2
* wal_buffers                     = 4MB
* min_wal_size                    = 80MB
* max_wal_size                    = 1GB
* random_page_cost                = 4
* default_statistics_target       = 100
* checkpoint_completion_target    = 0.9

Validating SQL fields in all layers of the tileset

Running all layers test "bbox_test_1" at zoom 0 (1 tiles) - 5.4172943,-1.6732196,12.3733400,4.3475256...
Tile sizes for 1 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:02.1 (0.5 tiles/s -20.3%)
#####################################################################################
█████████████████████████████ 16.8K avg size ±0.0%, 17,238B (0/0/0) — 17,238B (0/0/0)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_1" at zoom 1 (2 tiles) - 5.4172943,-1.6732196,12.3733400,4.3475256...
Tile sizes for 2 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.3 (5.7 tiles/s -5.3%)
#####################################################################################
█████                       30.0K avg size ±0.0%, 30,741B (1/1/1) — 30,741B (1/1/1)  
██████████████████████████ 139.2K avg size ±0.0%, 142,500B (1/1/0) — 142,500B (1/1/0)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_1" at zoom 2 (2 tiles) - 5.4172943,-1.6732196,12.3733400,4.3475256...
Tile sizes for 2 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.5 (3.3 tiles/s -33.9%)
#####################################################################################
█████                       29.1K avg size ±0.0%, 29,773B (2/2/2) — 29,773B (2/2/2)  
██████████████████████████ 126.8K avg size ±0.0%, 129,882B (2/2/1) — 129,882B (2/2/1)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_1" at zoom 3 (2 tiles) - 5.4172943,-1.6732196,12.3733400,4.3475256...
Tile sizes for 2 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.3 (5.3 tiles/s +4.3%)
#####################################################################################
██████████████████            27.4K avg size ±0.0%, 28,040B (3/4/4) — 28,040B (3/4/4)
█████████████████████████████ 42.9K avg size ±0.0%, 43,908B (3/4/3) — 43,908B (3/4/3)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_1" at zoom 4 (2 tiles) - 5.4172943,-1.6732196,12.3733400,4.3475256...
Tile sizes for 2 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.3 (5.0 tiles/s +30.7%)
#####################################################################################
███████████████               14.2K avg size ±0.0%, 14,517B (4/8/8) — 14,517B (4/8/8)
█████████████████████████████ 26.2K avg size ±0.0%, 26,810B (4/8/7) — 26,810B (4/8/7)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_1" at zoom 5 (4 tiles) - 5.4172943,-1.6732196,12.3733400,4.3475256...
Tile sizes for 4 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.4 (10.0 tiles/s +12.8%)
#####################################################################################
██████████                 6.2K avg size ±0.0%, 6,363B (5/16/16) — 6,363B (5/16/16)  
████████████               7.6K avg size ±0.0%, 7,764B (5/17/16) — 7,764B (5/17/16)  
█████████████              8.2K avg size ±0.0%, 8,397B (5/17/15) — 8,397B (5/17/15)  
█████████████████████████ 14.7K avg size ±0.0%, 15,081B (5/16/15) — 15,081B (5/16/15)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_1" at zoom 6 (6 tiles) - 5.4172943,-1.6732196,12.3733400,4.3475256...
Tile sizes for 6 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.3 (17.0 tiles/s +5.0%)
#####################################################################################
████████                   5.8K avg size ±0.0%, 5,921B (6/32/32) — 5,921B (6/32/32)  
████████                   5.8K avg size ±0.0%, 5,953B (6/32/31) — 5,953B (6/32/31)  
█████████                  6.1K avg size ±0.0%, 6,208B (6/34/32) — 6,208B (6/34/32)  
█████████                  6.7K avg size ±0.0%, 6,832B (6/33/32) — 6,832B (6/33/32)  
████████████               8.4K avg size ±0.0%, 8,585B (6/34/31) — 8,585B (6/34/31)  
█████████████████████████ 16.7K avg size ±0.0%, 17,084B (6/33/31) — 17,084B (6/33/31)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_1" at zoom 7 (12 tiles) - 5.4172943,-1.6732196,12.3733400,4.3475256...
Tile sizes for 12 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.9 (12.6 tiles/s -17.9%)
#####################################################################################
                        1,001.5 avg size ±0.0%, 313B (7/65/62) — 1,690B (7/65/63)    
███                        3.2K avg size ±0.0%, 3,250B (7/65/64) — 3,250B (7/65/64)  
██████                     6.8K avg size ±0.0%, 6,990B (7/68/64) — 6,990B (7/68/64)  
███████                    8.0K avg size ±0.0%, 8,225B (7/66/64) — 8,225B (7/66/64)  
███████                    8.1K avg size ±0.0%, 8,249B (7/67/64) — 8,249B (7/67/64)  
█████████                 10.4K avg size ±0.0%, 10,111B (7/68/62) — 11,142B (7/66/63)
███████████               12.5K avg size ±0.0%, 12,790B (7/66/62) — 12,790B (7/66/62)
████████████              13.3K avg size ±0.0%, 13,629B (7/68/63) — 13,629B (7/68/63)
███████████████           16.4K avg size ±0.0%, 16,779B (7/67/62) — 16,779B (7/67/62)
███████████████████████   24.3K avg size ±0.0%, 24,906B (7/67/63) — 24,906B (7/67/63)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_1" at zoom 8 (36 tiles) - 5.4172943,-1.6732196,12.3733400,4.3475256...
Tile sizes for 36 tiles (~4/line) done in 0:00:00.7 (46.8 tiles/s +18.5%)
#####################################################################################
                       68.8 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (8/136/124) — 156B (8/132/126)        
                      180.8 avg size ±0.0%, 158B (8/131/126) — 247B (8/131/124)      
                      660.7 avg size ±0.0%, 296B (8/134/129) — 1,386B (8/136/128)    
█                      1.8K avg size ±0.0%, 1,611B (8/131/127) — 2,070B (8/132/127)  
██                     2.5K avg size +0.6%, 2,211B (8/133/128) — 3,006B (8/133/127)  
███                    3.4K avg size ±0.0%, 3,405B (8/131/128) — 3,455B (8/132/129)  
█████                  5.5K avg size ±0.0%, 4,473B (8/135/124) — 6,169B (8/136/125)  
████████               7.8K avg size ±0.0%, 6,349B (8/133/126) — 9,234B (8/136/127)  
████████████          11.3K avg size -0.2%, 9,529B (8/134/127) — 13,184B (8/135/127) 
█████████████████████ 19.2K avg size -0.3%, 16,572B (8/134/126) — 24,787B (8/135/126)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_1" at zoom 9 (110 tiles) - 5.4172943,-1.6732196,12.3733400,4.3475256...
Tile sizes for 110 tiles (~11/line) done in 0:00:00.8 (120.7 tiles/s +36.4%)
#####################################################################################
                        0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (9/270/249) — 0B (9/272/256)          
                        7.5 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (9/273/256) — 82B (9/265/250)         
                       95.4 avg size ±0.0%, 82B (9/266/250) — 107B (9/266/252)       
                      107.6 avg size ±0.0%, 107B (9/263/253) — 111B (9/266/254)      
                      159.4 avg size ±0.0%, 120B (9/268/258) — 215B (9/269/258)      
█                     727.9 avg size ±0.0%, 229B (9/269/256) — 1,540B (9/272/255)    
██                     1.8K avg size ±0.0%, 1,604B (9/270/251) — 2,196B (9/265/257)  
█████                  3.2K avg size +0.0%, 2,228B (9/273/253) — 4,033B (9/264/257)  
█████████              6.1K avg size -0.0%, 4,182B (9/263/258) — 9,981B (9/271/254)  
█████████████████████ 13.2K avg size +0.0%, 10,324B (9/272/253) — 22,736B (9/271/253)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_1" at zoom 10 (378 tiles) - 5.4172943,-1.6732196,12.3733400,4.3475256...
Tile sizes for 378 tiles (~38/line) done in 0:00:03.7 (100.1 tiles/s +14.4%)
#####################################################################################
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (10/538/499) — 0B (10/545/503)         
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (10/546/503) — 0B (10/539/514)         
                      23.1 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (10/540/514) — 82B (10/531/501)        
                      82.0 avg size ±0.0%, 82B (10/532/501) — 82B (10/533/509)       
                      87.5 avg size ±0.0%, 82B (10/534/509) — 106B (10/528/506)      
                     106.7 avg size ±0.0%, 106B (10/536/506) — 107B (10/531/512)     
                     128.0 avg size ±0.0%, 107B (10/532/512) — 160B (10/527/511)     
█                    529.3 avg size ±0.0%, 160B (10/535/511) — 1,487B (10/544/509)   
██████                2.4K avg size ±0.0%, 1,494B (10/537/509) — 4,391B (10/537/503) 
████████████████████  7.9K avg size ±0.0%, 4,456B (10/538/509) — 16,367B (10/536/501)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_1" at zoom 11 (1,435 tiles) - 5.4172943,-1.6732196,12.3733400,4.3475256...
Tile sizes for 1,435 tiles (~144/line) done in 0:00:02.3 (603.8 tiles/s +14.2%)
#########################################################################################
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (11/1076/999) — 0B (11/1092/1008)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (11/1093/1008) — 0B (11/1094/1027)         
                      15.2 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (11/1076/1028) — 76B (11/1087/1022)        
                      81.9 avg size ±0.0%, 76B (11/1088/1022) — 82B (11/1069/1009)       
                      82.0 avg size ±0.0%, 82B (11/1070/1009) — 82B (11/1066/1017)       
                      82.0 avg size ±0.0%, 82B (11/1067/1017) — 82B (11/1061/1028)       
                      90.7 avg size ±0.0%, 82B (11/1062/1028) — 106B (11/1056/1028)      
                     108.3 avg size ±0.0%, 106B (11/1056/1029) — 132B (11/1076/1021)     
██                   605.3 avg size ±0.0%, 132B (11/1075/1032) — 1,632B (11/1061/1023)   
████████████████████  4.0K avg size ±0.0%, 1,634B (11/1082/1017) — 15,513B (11/1073/1002)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_1" at zoom 12 (5,600 tiles) - 5.4172943,-1.6732196,12.3733400,4.3475256...
Tile sizes for 5,600 tiles (~560/line) done in 0:00:25.4 (220.4 tiles/s +14.9%)
#######################################################################################
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/2117/1998) — 0B (12/2188/2015)       
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/2161/2016) — 0B (12/2167/2053)       
                       2.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/2168/2053) — 70B (12/2183/2034)      
                      78.8 avg size ±0.0%, 70B (12/2184/2034) — 82B (12/2133/2009)     
                      82.0 avg size ±0.0%, 82B (12/2134/2009) — 82B (12/2141/2024)     
                      82.0 avg size ±0.0%, 82B (12/2142/2024) — 82B (12/2138/2038)     
                      82.0 avg size ±0.0%, 82B (12/2139/2038) — 82B (12/2118/2055)     
                      86.5 avg size ±0.0%, 82B (12/2119/2055) — 106B (12/2144/2051)    
█                    180.0 avg size ±0.0%, 106B (12/2112/2052) — 574B (12/2160/2016)   
████████████████████  3.0K avg size ±0.0%, 578B (12/2156/2042) — 68,894B (12/2147/2005)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_1" at zoom 13 (22,101 tiles) - 5.4172943,-1.6732196,12.3733400,4.3475256...
Tile sizes for 22,101 tiles (~2210/line) done in 0:00:31.8 (692.2 tiles/s -4.2%)
######################################################################################
                      0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/4232/3996) — 0B (13/4353/4030)       
                      0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/4354/4030) — 0B (13/4322/4102)       
                      0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/4323/4102) — 0B (13/4349/4131)       
                     68.2 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/4350/4131) — 82B (13/4270/4009)      
█                    82.0 avg size ±0.0%, 82B (13/4271/4009) — 82B (13/4311/4036)     
█                    82.0 avg size ±0.0%, 82B (13/4312/4036) — 82B (13/4235/4061)     
█                    82.0 avg size ±0.0%, 82B (13/4236/4061) — 82B (13/4220/4087)     
█                    82.0 avg size ±0.0%, 82B (13/4221/4087) — 82B (13/4219/4117)     
█                    91.0 avg size ±0.0%, 82B (13/4220/4117) — 108B (13/4291/4031)    
████████████████████ 1.4K avg size -0.0%, 108B (13/4292/4031) — 48,100B (13/4295/4010)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_1" at zoom 14 (87,768 tiles) - 5.4172943,-1.6732196,12.3733400,4.3475256...
Tile sizes for 87,768 tiles (~8777/line) done in 0:01:34 (932.7 tiles/s ±0.0%)
######################################################################################
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/8463/7993) — 0B (14/8684/8061)      
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/8685/8061) — 0B (14/8721/8200)      
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/8722/8200) — 0B (14/8733/8258)      
█                     62.9 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/8734/8258) — 82B (14/8570/8011)     
██                    82.0 avg size ±0.0%, 82B (14/8571/8011) — 82B (14/8503/8060)    
██                    82.0 avg size ±0.0%, 82B (14/8504/8060) — 82B (14/8563/8107)    
██                    82.0 avg size ±0.0%, 82B (14/8564/8107) — 82B (14/8503/8156)    
██                    82.0 avg size ±0.0%, 82B (14/8504/8156) — 82B (14/8507/8209)    
██                    82.0 avg size ±0.0%, 82B (14/8508/8209) — 82B (14/8463/8265)    
████████████████████ 811.8 avg size -0.0%, 82B (14/8464/8265) — 71,282B (14/8591/8021)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_2" at zoom 0 (1 tiles) - 9.0900979,46.9688169,9.6717077,47.5258072...
Tile sizes for 1 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00 (19.1 tiles/s +0.5%)
#####################################################################################
█████████████████████████████ 16.8K avg size ±0.0%, 17,238B (0/0/0) — 17,238B (0/0/0)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_2" at zoom 1 (1 tiles) - 9.0900979,46.9688169,9.6717077,47.5258072...
Tile sizes for 1 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00 (17.5 tiles/s -0.5%)
#####################################################################################
██████████████████████████ 139.2K avg size ±0.0%, 142,500B (1/1/0) — 142,500B (1/1/0)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_2" at zoom 2 (1 tiles) - 9.0900979,46.9688169,9.6717077,47.5258072...
Tile sizes for 1 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00 (15.7 tiles/s -0.4%)
#####################################################################################
██████████████████████████ 126.8K avg size ±0.0%, 129,882B (2/2/1) — 129,882B (2/2/1)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_2" at zoom 3 (1 tiles) - 9.0900979,46.9688169,9.6717077,47.5258072...
Tile sizes for 1 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00 (11.2 tiles/s +20.6%)
#####################################################################################
█████████████████████████████ 63.7K avg size ±0.0%, 65,222B (3/4/2) — 65,222B (3/4/2)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_2" at zoom 4 (1 tiles) - 9.0900979,46.9688169,9.6717077,47.5258072...
Tile sizes for 1 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.1 (6.8 tiles/s +8.2%)
#####################################################################################
█████████████████████████████ 42.6K avg size ±0.0%, 43,590B (4/8/5) — 43,590B (4/8/5)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_2" at zoom 5 (1 tiles) - 9.0900979,46.9688169,9.6717077,47.5258072...
Tile sizes for 1 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.1 (9.3 tiles/s -15.3%)
#####################################################################################
█████████████████████████ 12.2K avg size ±0.0%, 12,527B (5/16/11) — 12,527B (5/16/11)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_2" at zoom 6 (1 tiles) - 9.0900979,46.9688169,9.6717077,47.5258072...
Tile sizes for 1 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00 (16.9 tiles/s -1.5%)
#####################################################################################
████████████████████████████ 5.7K avg size ±0.0%, 5,824B (6/33/22) — 5,824B (6/33/22)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_2" at zoom 7 (2 tiles) - 9.0900979,46.9688169,9.6717077,47.5258072...
Tile sizes for 2 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.2 (6.8 tiles/s -20.2%)
#####################################################################################
███████████████████          6.1K avg size ±0.0%, 6,241B (7/67/45) — 6,241B (7/67/45)
████████████████████████████ 8.7K avg size ±0.0%, 8,949B (7/67/44) — 8,949B (7/67/44)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_2" at zoom 8 (2 tiles) - 9.0900979,46.9688169,9.6717077,47.5258072...
Tile sizes for 2 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.2 (9.2 tiles/s +4.6%)
#####################################################################################
█████████████            6.0K avg size ±0.0%, 6,173B (8/134/90) — 6,173B (8/134/90)  
███████████████████████ 10.3K avg size ±0.0%, 10,520B (8/134/89) — 10,520B (8/134/89)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_2" at zoom 9 (6 tiles) - 9.0900979,46.9688169,9.6717077,47.5258072...
Tile sizes for 6 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.2 (20.2 tiles/s -32.2%)
#####################################################################################
████                   5.3K avg size ±0.0%, 5,457B (9/268/178) — 5,457B (9/268/178)  
████                   5.3K avg size ±0.0%, 5,457B (9/268/179) — 5,457B (9/268/179)  
████                   5.3K avg size ±0.0%, 5,457B (9/268/180) — 5,457B (9/268/180)  
█████                  5.5K avg size ±0.0%, 5,621B (9/269/178) — 5,621B (9/269/178)  
████████               9.8K avg size ±0.0%, 10,050B (9/269/180) — 10,050B (9/269/180)
█████████████████████ 23.0K avg size ±0.0%, 23,515B (9/269/179) — 23,515B (9/269/179)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_2" at zoom 10 (12 tiles) - 9.0900979,46.9688169,9.6717077,47.5258072...
Tile sizes for 12 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:01.2 (9.8 tiles/s +3.3%)
######################################################################################
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (10/537/357) — 0B (10/537/358)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (10/537/359) — 0B (10/537/359)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (10/537/360) — 0B (10/537/360)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (10/538/357) — 0B (10/538/357)          
                     142.0 avg size ±0.0%, 142B (10/539/357) — 142B (10/539/357)      
█████                10.5K avg size ±0.0%, 10,023B (10/538/358) — 11,386B (10/539/358)
█████                11.5K avg size ±0.0%, 11,776B (10/538/360) — 11,776B (10/538/360)
█████                12.1K avg size ±0.0%, 12,358B (10/539/360) — 12,358B (10/539/360)
███████              15.1K avg size ±0.0%, 15,434B (10/538/359) — 15,434B (10/538/359)
████████████████████ 40.9K avg size ±0.0%, 41,832B (10/539/359) — 41,832B (10/539/359)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_2" at zoom 11 (30 tiles) - 9.0900979,46.9688169,9.6717077,47.5258072...
Tile sizes for 30 tiles (~3/line) done in 0:00:00.5 (54.4 tiles/s -8.8%)
########################################################################################
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (11/1075/715) — 0B (11/1075/717)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (11/1075/718) — 0B (11/1075/720)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (11/1076/715) — 0B (11/1076/717)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (11/1076/718) — 0B (11/1076/720)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (11/1077/715) — 0B (11/1079/715)          
                     242.0 avg size ±0.0%, 140B (11/1079/716) — 378B (11/1078/716)      
██                    5.0K avg size ±0.0%, 4,574B (11/1077/717) — 6,148B (11/1079/720)  
████                  8.1K avg size ±0.0%, 6,780B (11/1078/717) — 9,777B (11/1078/720)  
██████               11.8K avg size ±0.0%, 11,112B (11/1079/718) — 13,672B (11/1077/718)
████████████████████ 38.3K avg size ±0.0%, 14,749B (11/1077/719) — 54,787B (11/1078/719)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_2" at zoom 12 (88 tiles) - 9.0900979,46.9688169,9.6717077,47.5258072...
Tile sizes for 88 tiles (~9/line) done in 0:00:12.1 (7.2 tiles/s -0.9%)
##########################################################################################
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/2151/1431) — 0B (12/2151/1439)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/2151/1440) — 0B (12/2152/1437)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/2152/1438) — 0B (12/2153/1435)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/2153/1436) — 0B (12/2154/1433)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/2154/1434) — 0B (12/2154/1441)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/2155/1431) — 0B (12/2156/1434)          
                      30.4 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/2157/1441) — 167B (12/2157/1431)        
                     912.4 avg size ±0.0%, 234B (12/2158/1432) — 2,373B (12/2155/1435)    
██                    6.2K avg size ±0.0%, 2,609B (12/2157/1435) — 15,306B (12/2155/1439) 
████████████████████ 43.8K avg size ±0.0%, 16,325B (12/2155/1437) — 85,837B (12/2156/1437)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_2" at zoom 13 (300 tiles) - 9.0900979,46.9688169,9.6717077,47.5258072...
Tile sizes for 300 tiles (~30/line) done in 0:00:03.1 (95.2 tiles/s +0.6%)
#########################################################################################
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/4302/2863) — 0B (13/4303/2872)         
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/4303/2873) — 0B (13/4304/2882)         
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/4305/2863) — 0B (13/4306/2872)         
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/4306/2873) — 0B (13/4307/2882)         
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/4308/2863) — 0B (13/4309/2872)         
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/4309/2873) — 0B (13/4311/2863)         
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/4311/2864) — 0B (13/4314/2865)         
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/4314/2866) — 0B (13/4316/2882)         
                      1.3K avg size ±0.0%, 103B (13/4316/2866) — 3,715B (13/4311/2876)   
████████████████████ 26.5K avg size +0.0%, 4,188B (13/4312/2880) — 56,460B (13/4313/2877)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_2" at zoom 14 (1,064 tiles) - 9.0900979,46.9688169,9.6717077,47.5258072...
Tile sizes for 1,064 tiles (~106/line) done in 0:00:08.4 (126.4 tiles/s -4.0%)
##########################################################################################
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/8605/5727) — 0B (14/8607/5757)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/8607/5758) — 0B (14/8610/5749)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/8610/5750) — 0B (14/8613/5742)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/8613/5743) — 0B (14/8616/5734)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/8616/5735) — 0B (14/8618/5764)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/8619/5727) — 0B (14/8621/5759)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/8621/5760) — 0B (14/8626/5727)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/8626/5728) — 0B (14/8631/5743)          
                     311.9 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/8631/5744) — 1,598B (14/8630/5759)      
████████████████████ 22.2K avg size -0.0%, 1,765B (14/8629/5748) — 105,806B (14/8625/5753)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_3" at zoom 0 (1 tiles) - -78.7749754,38.7820235,-76.8957735,39.6985009...
Tile sizes for 1 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00 (20.7 tiles/s +1.3%)
#####################################################################################
█████████████████████████████ 16.8K avg size ±0.0%, 17,238B (0/0/0) — 17,238B (0/0/0)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_3" at zoom 1 (1 tiles) - -78.7749754,38.7820235,-76.8957735,39.6985009...
Tile sizes for 1 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00 (20.9 tiles/s +0.7%)
#####################################################################################
█████████████████████████████ 43.9K avg size ±0.0%, 44,939B (1/0/0) — 44,939B (1/0/0)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_3" at zoom 2 (1 tiles) - -78.7749754,38.7820235,-76.8957735,39.6985009...
Tile sizes for 1 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00 (14.3 tiles/s +2.7%)
#####################################################################################
█████████████████████████████ 45.6K avg size ±0.0%, 46,702B (2/1/1) — 46,702B (2/1/1)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_3" at zoom 3 (1 tiles) - -78.7749754,38.7820235,-76.8957735,39.6985009...
Tile sizes for 1 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00 (20.3 tiles/s -4.6%)
#####################################################################################
█████████████████████████████ 22.5K avg size ±0.0%, 23,019B (3/2/3) — 23,019B (3/2/3)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_3" at zoom 4 (1 tiles) - -78.7749754,38.7820235,-76.8957735,39.6985009...
Tile sizes for 1 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00 (12.1 tiles/s +9.0%)
#####################################################################################
█████████████████████████████ 12.6K avg size ±0.0%, 12,932B (4/4/6) — 12,932B (4/4/6)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_3" at zoom 5 (2 tiles) - -78.7749754,38.7820235,-76.8957735,39.6985009...
Tile sizes for 2 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.1 (16.1 tiles/s +8.0%)
#####################################################################################
████████████████████         8.4K avg size ±0.0%, 8,594B (5/8/12) — 8,594B (5/8/12)  
███████████████████████████ 10.8K avg size ±0.0%, 11,054B (5/9/12) — 11,054B (5/9/12)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_3" at zoom 6 (2 tiles) - -78.7749754,38.7820235,-76.8957735,39.6985009...
Tile sizes for 2 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.1 (12.0 tiles/s +19.6%)
#####################################################################################
██                         2.9K avg size ±0.0%, 2,979B (6/17/24) — 2,979B (6/17/24)  
█████████████████████████ 29.5K avg size ±0.0%, 30,205B (6/18/24) — 30,205B (6/18/24)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_3" at zoom 7 (4 tiles) - -78.7749754,38.7820235,-76.8957735,39.6985009...
Tile sizes for 4 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.2 (15.9 tiles/s +4.9%)
#####################################################################################
██                         2.1K avg size ±0.0%, 2,171B (7/35/49) — 2,171B (7/35/49)  
███                        3.3K avg size ±0.0%, 3,370B (7/35/48) — 3,370B (7/35/48)  
████████████████████████  22.2K avg size ±0.0%, 22,701B (7/36/48) — 22,701B (7/36/48)
█████████████████████████ 22.4K avg size ±0.0%, 22,929B (7/36/49) — 22,929B (7/36/49)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_3" at zoom 8 (6 tiles) - -78.7749754,38.7820235,-76.8957735,39.6985009...
Tile sizes for 6 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.3 (19.6 tiles/s +9.3%)
#####################################################################################
                            0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (8/71/98) — 0B (8/71/98)          
                           1.1K avg size ±0.0%, 1,121B (8/71/97) — 1,121B (8/71/97)  
██                         3.3K avg size ±0.0%, 3,428B (8/72/98) — 3,428B (8/72/98)  
████                       5.9K avg size ±0.0%, 6,055B (8/72/97) — 6,055B (8/72/97)  
████████████████          20.4K avg size ±0.0%, 20,933B (8/73/98) — 20,933B (8/73/98)
█████████████████████████ 30.7K avg size ±0.0%, 31,457B (8/73/97) — 31,457B (8/73/97)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_3" at zoom 9 (12 tiles) - -78.7749754,38.7820235,-76.8957735,39.6985009...
Tile sizes for 12 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.3 (39.5 tiles/s -13.4%)
#####################################################################################
                        0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (9/143/195) — 0B (9/144/195)          
                        0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (9/143/196) — 0B (9/143/196)          
                        0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (9/144/196) — 0B (9/144/196)          
                       1.1K avg size ±0.0%, 1,177B (9/143/194) — 1,177B (9/143/194)  
                       1.9K avg size ±0.0%, 1,990B (9/146/194) — 1,990B (9/146/194)  
                       2.0K avg size ±0.0%, 1,990B (9/145/196) — 2,194B (9/144/194)  
█                      3.5K avg size ±0.0%, 3,617B (9/145/195) — 3,617B (9/145/195)  
█                      3.9K avg size ±0.0%, 3,948B (9/145/194) — 3,948B (9/145/194)  
███                    9.7K avg size ±0.0%, 9,982B (9/146/196) — 9,982B (9/146/196)  
█████████████████████ 55.4K avg size +0.0%, 56,681B (9/146/195) — 56,681B (9/146/195)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_3" at zoom 10 (35 tiles) - -78.7749754,38.7820235,-76.8957735,39.6985009...
Tile sizes for 35 tiles (~4/line) done in 0:00:05.1 (6.7 tiles/s +0.4%)
######################################################################################
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (10/288/388) — 0B (10/293/388)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (10/291/389) — 0B (10/293/389)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (10/287/390) — 0B (10/287/391)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (10/288/391) — 0B (10/290/391)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (10/287/392) — 0B (10/290/392)          
                      1.1K avg size ±0.0%, 1,034B (10/287/388) — 1,214B (10/287/389)  
                      1.5K avg size ±0.0%, 1,228B (10/290/390) — 2,105B (10/288/389)  
█                     2.2K avg size ±0.0%, 2,147B (10/293/390) — 2,418B (10/292/390)  
██                    3.8K avg size ±0.0%, 2,520B (10/290/389) — 6,066B (10/293/392)  
████████████████████ 33.4K avg size ±0.0%, 10,502B (10/292/392) — 63,612B (10/292/391)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_3" at zoom 11 (96 tiles) - -78.7749754,38.7820235,-76.8957735,39.6985009...
Tile sizes for 96 tiles (~10/line) done in 0:00:00.7 (124.4 tiles/s -14.8%)
#####################################################################################
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (11/576/777) — 0B (11/582/778)         
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (11/583/778) — 0B (11/580/779)         
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (11/582/779) — 0B (11/578/780)         
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (11/579/780) — 0B (11/579/781)         
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (11/580/781) — 0B (11/581/782)         
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (11/582/782) — 0B (11/583/783)         
                     104.3 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (11/575/784) — 1,043B (11/582/781)     
█                     1.2K avg size ±0.0%, 1,056B (11/575/777) — 1,351B (11/581/780) 
█                     1.7K avg size ±0.0%, 1,490B (11/579/777) — 2,063B (11/581/779) 
████████████████████ 19.4K avg size -0.0%, 3,528B (11/584/784) — 87,427B (11/585/783)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_3" at zoom 12 (322 tiles) - -78.7749754,38.7820235,-76.8957735,39.6985009...
Tile sizes for 322 tiles (~32/line) done in 0:00:25.7 (12.5 tiles/s +3.7%)
##########################################################################################
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/1152/1555) — 0B (12/1151/1557)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/1156/1557) — 0B (12/1168/1558)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/1169/1558) — 0B (12/1156/1560)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/1157/1560) — 0B (12/1171/1561)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/1172/1561) — 0B (12/1159/1563)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/1160/1563) — 0B (12/1156/1565)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/1157/1565) — 0B (12/1152/1567)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/1153/1567) — 0B (12/1166/1568)          
█                     1.1K avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/1167/1568) — 1,403B (12/1160/1556)      
████████████████████ 19.6K avg size -0.0%, 1,453B (12/1152/1556) — 195,147B (12/1171/1566)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_3" at zoom 13 (1,232 tiles) - -78.7749754,38.7820235,-76.8957735,39.6985009...
Tile sizes for 1,232 tiles (~123/line) done in 0:00:16.2 (75.7 tiles/s +1.5%)
##########################################################################################
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/2303/3110) — 0B (13/2328/3113)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/2329/3113) — 0B (13/2337/3116)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/2338/3116) — 0B (13/2335/3119)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/2336/3119) — 0B (13/2336/3122)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/2337/3122) — 0B (13/2331/3125)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/2334/3125) — 0B (13/2332/3128)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/2338/3128) — 0B (13/2303/3132)          
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/2304/3132) — 0B (13/2315/3135)          
                      96.1 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/2316/3135) — 1,084B (13/2319/3110)      
████████████████████ 13.1K avg size -0.0%, 1,092B (13/2312/3111) — 153,251B (13/2343/3133)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_3" at zoom 14 (4,785 tiles) - -78.7749754,38.7820235,-76.8957735,39.6985009...
Tile sizes for 4,785 tiles (~478/line) done in 0:00:46 (103.9 tiles/s -2.3%)
######################################################################################
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/4606/6220) — 0B (14/4617/6226)      
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/4618/6226) — 0B (14/4633/6232)      
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/4634/6232) — 0B (14/4692/6237)      
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/4606/6238) — 0B (14/4668/6243)      
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/4669/6243) — 0B (14/4637/6249)      
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/4638/6249) — 0B (14/4613/6255)      
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/4614/6255) — 0B (14/4691/6260)      
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/4692/6260) — 0B (14/4624/6267)      
                       0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/4625/6267) — 0B (14/4630/6273)      
████████████████████ 29.9K avg size +0.0%, 0B (14/4631/6273) — 587,314B (14/4688/6267)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_4" at zoom 0 (1 tiles) - -0.6124681,51.2268449,0.3996690,51.7873570...
Tile sizes for 1 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00 (19.8 tiles/s +2.8%)
#####################################################################################
█████████████████████████████ 16.8K avg size ±0.0%, 17,238B (0/0/0) — 17,238B (0/0/0)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_4" at zoom 1 (2 tiles) - -0.6124681,51.2268449,0.3996690,51.7873570...
Tile sizes for 2 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00 (30.0 tiles/s +0.8%)
#####################################################################################
████████                    43.9K avg size ±0.0%, 44,939B (1/0/0) — 44,939B (1/0/0)  
██████████████████████████ 139.2K avg size ±0.0%, 142,500B (1/1/0) — 142,500B (1/1/0)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_4" at zoom 2 (2 tiles) - -0.6124681,51.2268449,0.3996690,51.7873570...
Tile sizes for 2 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00 (24.5 tiles/s +0.5%)
#####################################################################################
█████████                   45.6K avg size ±0.0%, 46,702B (2/1/1) — 46,702B (2/1/1)  
██████████████████████████ 126.8K avg size ±0.0%, 129,882B (2/2/1) — 129,882B (2/2/1)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_4" at zoom 3 (2 tiles) - -0.6124681,51.2268449,0.3996690,51.7873570...
Tile sizes for 2 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00 (20.1 tiles/s +24.0%)
#####################################################################################
███████                       16.2K avg size ±0.0%, 16,586B (3/3/2) — 16,586B (3/3/2)
█████████████████████████████ 63.7K avg size ±0.0%, 65,222B (3/4/2) — 65,222B (3/4/2)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_4" at zoom 4 (2 tiles) - -0.6124681,51.2268449,0.3996690,51.7873570...
Tile sizes for 2 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00 (25.1 tiles/s +6.1%)
#####################################################################################
████████                      12.5K avg size ±0.0%, 12,766B (4/7/5) — 12,766B (4/7/5)
█████████████████████████████ 42.6K avg size ±0.0%, 43,590B (4/8/5) — 43,590B (4/8/5)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_4" at zoom 5 (2 tiles) - -0.6124681,51.2268449,0.3996690,51.7873570...
Tile sizes for 2 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.1 (15.2 tiles/s -37.5%)
#####################################################################################
████████████████████████  11.2K avg size ±0.0%, 11,505B (5/16/10) — 11,505B (5/16/10)
█████████████████████████ 11.7K avg size ±0.0%, 11,935B (5/15/10) — 11,935B (5/15/10)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_4" at zoom 6 (2 tiles) - -0.6124681,51.2268449,0.3996690,51.7873570...
Tile sizes for 2 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.1 (13.8 tiles/s +38.6%)
#####################################################################################
█████████████             14.8K avg size ±0.0%, 15,138B (6/32/21) — 15,138B (6/32/21)
█████████████████████████ 27.3K avg size ±0.0%, 27,987B (6/31/21) — 27,987B (6/31/21)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_4" at zoom 7 (2 tiles) - -0.6124681,51.2268449,0.3996690,51.7873570...
Tile sizes for 2 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.2 (7.4 tiles/s +20.4%)
#####################################################################################
████████████              37.5K avg size ±0.0%, 38,379B (7/64/42) — 38,379B (7/64/42)
█████████████████████████ 73.0K avg size ±0.0%, 74,704B (7/63/42) — 74,704B (7/63/42)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_4" at zoom 8 (4 tiles) - -0.6124681,51.2268449,0.3996690,51.7873570...
Tile sizes for 4 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.4 (7.5 tiles/s +19.8%)
#####################################################################################
██                    19.3K avg size ±0.0%, 19,722B (8/128/84) — 19,722B (8/128/84)  
███                   27.6K avg size ±0.0%, 28,286B (8/127/84) — 28,286B (8/127/84)  
███████               64.4K avg size ±0.0%, 65,934B (8/128/85) — 65,934B (8/128/85)  
████████████████████ 177.2K avg size +0.0%, 181,462B (8/127/85) — 181,462B (8/127/85)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_4" at zoom 9 (4 tiles) - -0.6124681,51.2268449,0.3996690,51.7873570...
Tile sizes for 4 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:00.5 (6.6 tiles/s +8.6%)
#######################################################################################
█                     24.2K avg size +0.1%, 24,792B (9/256/169) — 24,792B (9/256/169)  
███                   45.2K avg size +0.0%, 46,258B (9/255/169) — 46,258B (9/255/169)  
███████              106.9K avg size +0.0%, 109,440B (9/256/170) — 109,440B (9/256/170)
████████████████████ 288.9K avg size +0.0%, 295,802B (9/255/170) — 295,802B (9/255/170)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_4" at zoom 10 (12 tiles) - -0.6124681,51.2268449,0.3996690,51.7873570...
Tile sizes for 12 tiles (~1/line) done in 0:00:11 (1.1 tiles/s +3.0%)
#########################################################################################
                       6.6K avg size ±0.0%, 6,426B (10/513/339) — 7,113B (10/513/341)    
                      10.6K avg size ±0.0%, 10,835B (10/513/340) — 10,835B (10/513/340)  
█                     26.5K avg size ±0.0%, 27,108B (10/510/339) — 27,108B (10/510/339)  
█                     26.5K avg size ±0.0%, 27,145B (10/510/341) — 27,145B (10/510/341)  
█                     34.3K avg size ±0.0%, 35,142B (10/512/339) — 35,142B (10/512/339)  
███                   63.3K avg size ±0.0%, 59,424B (10/512/341) — 70,304B (10/511/339)  
████                  89.8K avg size ±0.0%, 91,986B (10/511/341) — 91,986B (10/511/341)  
█████                103.4K avg size ±0.0%, 105,839B (10/510/340) — 105,839B (10/510/340)
████████             150.5K avg size ±0.0%, 154,062B (10/512/340) — 154,062B (10/512/340)
████████████████████ 373.2K avg size +0.0%, 382,138B (10/511/340) — 382,138B (10/511/340)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_4" at zoom 11 (42 tiles) - -0.6124681,51.2268449,0.3996690,51.7873570...
Tile sizes for 42 tiles (~4/line) done in 0:00:01.9 (21.3 tiles/s +5.8%)
###########################################################################################
                      634.6 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (11/1020/678) — 1,243B (11/1025/678)        
                       2.7K avg size ±0.0%, 1,777B (11/1021/678) — 3,734B (11/1021/683)    
                       4.5K avg size ±0.0%, 3,926B (11/1025/683) — 5,001B (11/1020/679)    
                       5.4K avg size -0.1%, 5,286B (11/1020/682) — 5,779B (11/1026/680)    
                       9.1K avg size +0.0%, 7,813B (11/1022/683) — 10,063B (11/1020/681)   
█                     18.7K avg size +0.1%, 13,029B (11/1025/682) — 27,158B (11/1021/682)  
████                  52.3K avg size +0.0%, 37,557B (11/1025/681) — 71,686B (11/1025/680)  
████████              90.0K avg size +0.0%, 85,514B (11/1022/682) — 104,879B (11/1021/680) 
███████████          126.6K avg size -0.0%, 114,199B (11/1021/681) — 144,262B (11/1024/680)
████████████████████ 216.2K avg size +0.1%, 182,035B (11/1022/681) — 269,138B (11/1023/680)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_4" at zoom 12 (144 tiles) - -0.6124681,51.2268449,0.3996690,51.7873570...
Tile sizes for 144 tiles (~14/line) done in 0:01:13.5 (2.0 tiles/s +0.5%)
#############################################################################################
                        0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/2041/1356) — 0B (12/2043/1367)            
                        0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/2044/1356) — 0B (12/2050/1357)            
                        0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (12/2050/1367) — 0B (12/2052/1367)            
                       1.0K avg size ±0.0%, 911B (12/2043/1358) — 1,355B (12/2052/1362)      
                       2.1K avg size ±0.0%, 1,591B (12/2052/1360) — 2,904B (12/2042/1364)    
                       6.8K avg size ±0.0%, 3,013B (12/2041/1360) — 13,644B (12/2050/1359)   
██                    25.6K avg size ±0.0%, 15,232B (12/2044/1365) — 47,494B (12/2042/1360)  
███████               79.6K avg size +0.0%, 58,118B (12/2048/1365) — 101,786B (12/2046/1359) 
███████████          120.2K avg size -0.0%, 103,899B (12/2047/1364) — 153,772B (12/2045/1360)
████████████████████ 214.6K avg size +0.0%, 157,230B (12/2045/1363) — 337,785B (12/2046/1361)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_4" at zoom 13 (528 tiles) - -0.6124681,51.2268449,0.3996690,51.7873570...
Tile sizes for 528 tiles (~53/line) done in 0:01:57.2 (4.5 tiles/s +0.1%)
############################################################################################
                        0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/4082/2713) — 0B (13/4090/2715)           
                        0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/4091/2715) — 0B (13/4086/2718)           
                        0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/4098/2718) — 0B (13/4084/2730)           
                        0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/4085/2730) — 0B (13/4099/2733)           
                      302.5 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (13/4100/2733) — 991B (13/4095/2713)         
                       2.3K avg size ±0.0%, 1,005B (13/4101/2718) — 5,988B (13/4097/2719)   
██                    15.8K avg size +0.0%, 6,056B (13/4099/2730) — 29,665B (13/4093/2731)  
███████               39.7K avg size -0.0%, 30,431B (13/4097/2731) — 51,101B (13/4092/2718) 
███████████           61.3K avg size -0.0%, 51,314B (13/4094/2728) — 75,226B (13/4090/2722) 
████████████████████ 110.5K avg size -0.0%, 75,543B (13/4093/2720) — 215,746B (13/4093/2723)


Running all layers test "bbox_test_4" at zoom 14 (1,974 tiles) - -0.6124681,51.2268449,0.3996690,51.7873570...
Tile sizes for 1,974 tiles (~197/line) done in 0:01:43.7 (19.0 tiles/s -1.7%)
#############################################################################################
                        0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/8164/5427) — 0B (14/8180/5431)            
                        0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/8181/5431) — 0B (14/8169/5436)            
                        0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/8170/5436) — 0B (14/8170/5456)            
                        0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/8201/5456) — 0B (14/8184/5464)            
                        0.0 avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/8189/5464) — 0B (14/8204/5468)            
                       1.4K avg size ±0.0%, 0B (14/8205/5468) — 4,738B (14/8190/5434)        
█                     14.4K avg size -0.0%, 4,747B (14/8196/5462) — 27,565B (14/8196/5442)   
███                   39.7K avg size -0.0%, 27,873B (14/8188/5459) — 55,515B (14/8185/5459)  
██████                73.2K avg size +0.0%, 56,173B (14/8195/5447) — 101,530B (14/8179/5449) 
████████████████████ 211.6K avg size -0.0%, 102,178B (14/8178/5448) — 873,375B (14/8185/5447)

@TomPohys
Copy link
Member

Thanks! Maybe one improvement for valley should be LineLabel function (example in water_name layer). Some of the valleys could be very short even for zoom 13 e.g. https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/451566241.

openmaptiles/layers/water_name/water_name.sql

Line 34 in 6c31841

AND ((zoom_level BETWEEN 3 AND 13 AND LineLabel(zoom_level, NULLIF(name, ''), geometry))

@TomPohys TomPohys added this to the v3.15 milestone Dec 1, 2023
@zstadler
Copy link
Contributor Author

Thanks! Maybe one improvement for valley should be LineLabel function (example in water_name layer). Some of the valleys could be very short even for zoom 13 e.g. https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/451566241.

openmaptiles/layers/water_name/water_name.sql

Line 34 in 6c31841

AND ((zoom_level BETWEEN 3 AND 13 AND LineLabel(zoom_level, NULLIF(name, ''), geometry))

LGTM

@TomPohys
Copy link
Member

Adding the LineLabel will be beneficial. Also please consider excluding the valley without name (or how you would like to style just the line?). Could you please update the style to show the names of the valleys?

Could you please update the PR?

Thanks!

@zstadler
Copy link
Contributor Author

zstadler commented Dec 19, 2023 •
edited

@TomPohys,

On second thought, I prefer not to expand this PR. The intention here is for a minimal addition to the layer where natural=valley would follow the existing handling of other linestring elements, such as natural=arete.

Each of the two recommendations require a non-trivial enhancement of the layer:

  1. If the LineLabel function is used, it should be applied to all linestring features, probably except natural=cliff.
  2. The style does not seem to handle linestring elements appropriately. They are handled as if they were a point element. As a result:
    • Cliffs are not shown at all
    • A peak icon is used for all other elements, even for a natural=arete
    • The icon and the name are positioned at the edge of the line, rather than at the center or along the line itself

I prefer that these enhancements will be put in a separate issue/s that would be handled by a different person.

@ZeLonewolf
Copy link
Contributor

Cliffs, ridges, and arêtes are all commonly rendered on maps as a line feature without labelling (though I would love to have labelled ridges in OpenMapTiles). Valleys on the other hand are rarely rendered on maps as a line feature only - they are usually rendered only as a label feature. So the primary cartographic reason for the linestring for valleys are as placement for a label. So I'm not sure what benefit we really gain from adding valleys if we don't also include sufficient attributes (name and name:xx tags) as @TomPohys suggests to draw a label.

@TomPohys TomPohys removed this from the v3.15 milestone Feb 19, 2024
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Reviewers
No reviews
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

Missing natural data
3 participants
@zstadler @TomPohys @ZeLonewolf