V1.0.0-beta5 - Missing Material Properties: Meltingpoint, Boilingpoint, ... ?

[markdoerr]

Dear EMMO developers,

in the latest (beta 5) version of EMMO, quite important material properties, like melting point and boiling point are missing.
Were they omitted on purpose (because they are depending on other physical properties like pressure ) ?
(if this is the reason, one could use the conventional pressure, e.g. 1013 hPa )

[jesper-friis]

Dear Mark,
It is not a problem that the melting and boiling point depend on other properties, since EMMO consider a physical quantity as a sign produced by a measurement process. But we have limited the scope of the ISQ module in EMMO core to the ISO/IEC 80000 standard. The module is still not complete in the sense that it covers the full ISO/IEC 80000, but I don't find melting and boiling point in ISO/IEC 80000.

My suggestion would be to create an EMMO-based domain ontology that extend the ISQ module with additional thermodynamic physical quantities. @emanueleghedini, @jsimonclark, any thoughts from your side?

By the way, I see that melting point is defined in defined in ISO 23020, paragraph 3.1.13.

[markdoerr]

Thanks, Jesper,
for the fast reply. I agree that EMMO should limit the scope to be lean.
If melting points and boiling points are not too frequently used, a thermodynamic domain ontology would be a good idea.
Let's see, what @emanueleghedini and @jsimonclark reply.