-
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 3k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Add SIGGRAPH / SIGGRAPH Asia conference track #6858
Comments
Aren't these confs already included under the Interdisciplinary Areas? |
SIGGRAPH / SIGGRAPH Asia are already included in the list, but I guess the problem is that CSRankings counts SIGGRAPH / SIGGRAPH Asia papers only under the "ACM Trans. Graph." title. As przem-research said, the conference track papers are not published to TOG, so they are just listed under the conference name in DBLP, like my recent SIGGRAPH Asia conference paper: I believe the code for handling articles requires an update. |
@yssl Yes, this is exactly what I am saying. The conference track papers are not fetched from DBLP and hence not counted. @Xovee : I am not saying SIGGRAPH / Asia are not included, I am saying the new track is not fetched because it does not publish in the TOG journal, instead it is published in separate proceedings. This is more of an technical issue and @yssl correctly says a code update could fix it. |
Thanks for the replay. Csrankings is relied on dblp's data/api structures and there seems no way to automatically address this. |
@przem-research, @Xovee: After a closer examination of the code, it appears that the following line is not just counting TOG papers for SIGGRAPH / SIGGRAPH Asia, but is actually intended to count papers marked as TOG in DBLP that are from SIGGRAPH / SIGGRAPH Asia: CSrankings/util/regenerate_data.py Line 209 in 774a52c
According to the next line, both string 'ACM Trans. Graph.' and 'SIGGRAPH' are considered part of the 'siggraph' area, while 'ACM Trans. Graph.' and 'SIGGRAPH Asia' are both considered part of the 'siggraph-asia' area: Line 263 in 1e6ba81
The area items mentioned above are used in the next line to construct the CSrankings/util/regenerate_data.py Line 112 in 774a52c
And the next line retrieves the CSrankings/util/regenerate_data.py Line 182 in 774a52c
And the next line stops processing if the confname retrieved from DBLP does not exist in the CSrankings/util/regenerate_data.py Line 192 in 774a52c
In the data source used by csrankings, https://dblp.org/xml/dblp.xml.gz, TOG papers (whether they are SIGGRAPH, SIGGRAPH Asia papers, or pure TOG papers) have the following entry: SIGGRAPH Asia Conference Track papers have the following entry: And SIGGRAPH Conference Track papers have the following: Therefore, because 'SIGGRAPH', not 'SIGGRAPH (Conference Paper Track)' is stored in the However, what I don't understand is why SIGGRAPH Asia conference track papers, which have 'SIGGRAPH Asia' as the I would be grateful if someone who is knowledgeable about the relevant sections of the code could review and modify it to ensure that papers from the SIGGRAPH and SIGGRAPH Asia conference tracks are also counted. |
Dear Emery
Request: SIGGRAPH/SIGGRAPH Asia Conference papers are currently not counted. Please add.
Justification: SIGGRAPH introduced a new conference track, which is not published in the TOG journal. The conference papers are top tier full papers limited to 7 pages. They undergo the same rigorous review as journal papers and are comparable to conference papers in other disciplines (CVPR, ICLR, ICML, etc.).
See description:
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: