Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Watching long videos at 1.5x sometimes sends video back to beginning instead of skipping sponsor. #1889

Open
K4sum1 opened this issue Oct 21, 2023 · 17 comments

Comments

@K4sum1
Copy link

K4sum1 commented Oct 21, 2023

For most videos in a live stream or podcast format, I watch them at 1.5x. I've found for some videos that instead of skipping the sponsors, I get sent back to the beginning. This issue appears to come and go, so I'm not sure how repeatable it is, but I had it happen for this video.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aaiP7cQPwck

@ajayyy
Copy link
Owner

ajayyy commented Oct 21, 2023

Firefox? Segments at the end or other times?

@K4sum1
Copy link
Author

K4sum1 commented Oct 21, 2023

Yeah Firefox, specifically Developer Edition. The video I linked has two segments, both a good amount in the video. It's usually only these long Broken Silicon videos where I have had this happen. It happened for both of them in this video for me, and it happened for both in the previous video I think.

@ajayyy
Copy link
Owner

ajayyy commented Oct 21, 2023

But is it segments in the middle where it happens, or ones that skip to the end

@K4sum1
Copy link
Author

K4sum1 commented Oct 21, 2023

There's nothing at the end. If I reach the segments in the middle, I get sent back to the beginning.

@ajayyy
Copy link
Owner

ajayyy commented Oct 21, 2023

What may be happening is, when the skip happens, it causes it to change video resolutions due to taking too long to buffer (which causes the video time to be reset to zero). Normally, the video player gets reset to the correct position and it fixes itself, but maybe somehow the segment at the beginning auto skipping early enough is causing progress in the video to be lost. Would explain why it is only on 1.5x speed and with long videos.

@BaconCatBug
Copy link

BaconCatBug commented Nov 16, 2023

This is happening to me as well now. 2x speed, on firefox, with a mid-video segment. Instead of skipping to the end of the midroll segment, it resets back to the start. Perhaps whatever this bug was has regressed? #1861

@AsheIsAmazing
Copy link

Can confirm the same issue, also on firefox on videos with a beginning segment.

@j-bs
Copy link

j-bs commented Nov 19, 2023

Another confirmation of mid-video skip on firefox resetting the video here too. Watching on 2x

@4fosaefp
Copy link

I'm experience the same issue on Firefox. Happens occasionally even on shorter videos (~10min). I also watch at 1.5-2x speed.
When there's a sponsored segment at end of the video, it'll jump back to the start.

@Anizam
Copy link

Anizam commented Jan 31, 2024

Same problem with Firefox

Version 122.0 (64-bit)
Mozilla Firefox Snap for Ubuntu
canonical-002 - 1.0

Plugin

5.5.3

@D0han
Copy link

D0han commented Apr 7, 2024

Same, Firefox on Linux, usually 1.5-3.0 speed

@0ctoqus
Copy link

0ctoqus commented Apr 12, 2024

Same problem here in Firefox and windows when watching at 2x speed

@Chalenor
Copy link

Ditto. Watching this video at 1.5x in Firefox's default stable build in Windows 10 on 1 Gbps connection, and it can randomly occur during a segment skip: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K4oPpnAEvz8

@ajayyy
Copy link
Owner

ajayyy commented Apr 15, 2024

If anyone is able to catch a recording, that would help. Knowing timing of how quick it happens after the skip would make it possible for the extension to detect this and automatically seek back to where it was

@BaconCatBug
Copy link

No recording to hand, but it happens immediately. As in, the video progress touches the skip segment (e.g. the green sponsor segment), and the very next millisecond immediately zips back to the start of the video.

@Chalenor
Copy link

Got a video of the event here:

SBSegmentRestartsVideo.mp4

@ajayyy
Copy link
Owner

ajayyy commented Apr 16, 2024

thanks! Does look like it is changing resolutions

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

10 participants